Now that school has started, I am back to work again on writing my dissertation, up shortly after four am and to school before anybody else to sit and write quietly at my desk. I want to take a few moments now to capture in a blog post what I am doing and what I still need to do.
My primary emphasis right now is finishing my dissertation prospectus and getting it officially approved. The idea for the dissertation is essentially that many artists have been inspired by Shakespearean drama to re-create this themes, characters, and stories in their own medium. Mendelsohn wrote a symphony from A Midsummer Night’s Dream. Painters have depicted Shakespearean imagry and scenes in their paintings over the past three centuries. Sculpture, poetry, fiction and others have all taken Shakespeare and adapted it into something new and different. My dissertation aims to explore some of the creative things done with Shakespeare and then glean from it what teachers can use to get their own students excited about learning about Shakespeare.
That’s the idea. But right now I am focusing on the beginning still. And I’ve been focusing on the beginning for a long time now. I wrote a brief prospectus over the summer, but its was incomplete, and I’m working now on finishing up the bits and pieces I need to get the prospectus done.
One part of the dissertation is going to be about how Shakespeare came to be such an important figure in Education. Its a question that has plagued me since before I even read my first Shakespeare play. What is it about this one writer that makes him the king of our literary canon; does he deserve it and why? I’ve asked that question at least a million times, to myself, and to countless others. I’ve heard a lot of reasons, but remain unsatisfied still today. I know its more complex than most of teachers and scholars want to admit, and I want part of this dissertation to begin exploring that very complex question. The problem, though, is that I really don’t have a satisfactory answer at all. I suppose those are the best types of questions, but they are also mind boggling when you are at the beginning.
I’ve been re-reading Arthur Applebee’s “Tradition and Reform in the Teaching of English: a History” and going back to all of the parts where he addresses Shakespeare. He has a few good references to Shakespeare’s first appearance in school texts and classrooms beginning around 1820 in a marginal way, and much more significantly beginning around 1870 and building into the icon we know today about 1900.
He tells an interesting story from 1807, in which 99 out of 175 Harvard students purchase a collected works of Shakespeare plays for personal study. They do not buy the plays for their academic work, but to discuss them in their fraternal societies. The universities believed that reading modern works such as Shakespeare was good for students, but not appropriate for a rigorous study required in the classroom. That sounds so funny today, to suggest that Shakespeare is too “pop culture” to be appropriate in the classroom! Shakespeare, though, grew out of this non-academic tradition. I’d like to find more sources like this one to more fully paint the image of Shakespearean study at this time.
There was also some strong resentment to Shakespeare in the early 19th century around this time. Applebee writes that in 1828, a Boston teacher was dismissed because he read Shakespeare aloud in his classes. I’d like to know more details about that. What did he read to them? What forces pushed for his dismissal? There must be more to the story. I know that Shakespeare is filled with sex and violence (its why we all love him so) but I sense that this is a much more interesting story than Applebee relays to us. Also, at Oberlin, Shakespeare was not permitted in mixed gender classes until 1860. And even as late as 1893, the New England Journal of Education included an editorial supporting a class refusing to read Hamlet because of its “indecencies”.
This is my starting point right now. I have a few other sources to work from, but not a lot yet, and need more help finding more historical information. I do not believe there is actually an answer to my original question, not one that will satisfy me entirely, but I think persuing it will prove satisfying to me.